The SpartanNerd’s collection of Liliana cards…Commentary on Amonkhet Liliana(s)

 

IMG_0055

 

(nicknames for Liliana…..

Liliana Vess- (Why would you give this a nickname?)

Duel-iana (Alternate art Liliana Vess vs Garruk)

Pricey-ana (Liliana of the Veil)

Swamp-iana (Liliana of the Dark Realms)

Flip-iana (Liliana, Heretical Healer//Liliana, Defiant Necromancer)

Hope-iana (Liliana, the Last Hope)

Zombie-ana (Liliana, Death’s Majesty)

Slow-iana (Liliana, Death Wielder)

 

 

So with the release of AMONKHET, we now have not just one, but two new Liliana cards!

Liliana has long been my favorite planeswalker, as I owned Liliana Vess way back when I opened her in a core set pack that I purchased as I started to get into the game.  Liliana Vess plus Grave Titan was just AWESOME!

I continued a legacy of loving the cards as I drafted a Liliana Vess back in M15…and I remember when I began to get into standard heavily main-decking Liliana of the Dark Realms and I remember getting the emblem, and then spectacularly topdecking Rakdos Return for a win…everone in the room made a noise when I did that! (Wow!  AHHH!  Ugh!)  Topdecking stuff like that is one reason why I love playing black.

How did I get Liliana of the Veil…such an expensive and rare card?  A friend gave me a booster pack of Battle for Zendikar, and I opened a Zendikar Expedition Marsh Flats, which I traded for Liliana of the Veil.  Pricey-ana is an important piece of “the rack” deck, as well as an enabler for re-animation in the “Gifts Ungiven” deck.

My pet commander deck is Liliana, Heretical Healer.  And all of the Liliana cards I have had up until recently are in that deck…which brings us to the recent two versions of the cards.  (Oh yes.  You might be wondering if I marked on my cards…the little “ZZZ’s” are meant to remind me to get a Zombie when she flips!  Don’t worry, I wrote on the inner sleeve.  double sleeved)

LILIANA, DEATH’S MAJESTY

A five-drop Liliana.  But this is where the similarities to Liliana Vess end.  I think they costed her out at five though, because her top two abilities are absolutely use-able very relevant abilities that are worth five mana.  If she gets removed next turn, your investment was not in vain!  The art on this one is also some of the best art depicting the character.  I really do like how snobby and in-charge she appears.  Liliana is the ultimate “mean girl.”  Maybe I like the art on Heretical Healer//Defiant Necromancer better?  The -7 ability on this card is a sweeper.  But the problem is that little word, “destroy.”  There are a lot of indestructible creatures out there in standard, especially the new “god” cards.  But also Gideon.  Also that she only gets non-zombies can’t be ignored.  There are and will be mirror decks, as well as emergent zombie decks.

I wish I had a foil!

LILIANA, DEATH WIELDER

It hurts me to say this…this is one of the JANK-IEST CARDS ever printed.  (Janky-ana?)

You know those lists of bad cards that people sometimes make?  Liliana of the Dark Realms makes that list occasionally.  Yeah, yeah.  The flavor is a little off.  It takes a while to ultimate.  You have to play mono black pretty much.  And what’s with the hair?

But this card just bumped that Liliana off the list.  Why?

OK.  Seven Drop.  In a mono-black deck, it’s going to be at least a full seven turns before you play this, if you aren’t doing DARK RITUAL, or some other crazy acceleration trick.  Which most of the time you won’t be doing.  If you wanted ramp, your color would be green….

What else?  +2, put a -1/-1 counter on target creature.  By turn 7, your green opponent could have any number of gigantic threats.  Even White and Blue will have bigger creatures by turn seven.  What about red?  By turn seven, red already killed you if you were counting on this card to win you the game.  So let’s say you DO get a -1/-1 counter on a creature…

-3 Destroy target creature with a -1/-1 counter on it.

Let’s math for a minute.  3>2.  So.  you just lost that progress you made last turn, PLUS ANOTHER LOYALTY POINT.

How about her ultimate….

-10  Return all creature cards from your graveyard to the battlefield.

How is this ultimate not strictly, strictly, strictly worse than the original Liliana Vess’ ultimate ability, that takes all creatures from all graveyards and puts them on the battlefield under your control?

Now I’m quite aware why this card is the way it is.

The art is big and splashy.  A nice foil.  And new players will be attracted to the looks of this card.  Which is exactly the point.

Liliana, Death Wielder can only be gotten in a Planeswalker Deck, the equivalent of an intro pack, (which the Wizards don’t make any more.)  I can see a kid really digging this card.

But I think I am going to keep her in the Planeswalker Pack with the rest of her deck. She’s just too bad for my special commander deck.  I have played this card against the SpartanKid a couple of times, and found it to be lacking in every department except for the art and flavor departments.  I have yet to try it out against the Gideon Planeswalker deck, but all accounts out there on the internet say that his deck is better, and partly because his Planeswalker card is better.

 

 

Review of the Liliana Planeswalker Pack will be coming soon!

 

Advertisements

Modern Masters 2017…SpartanNerd Experience

I pre-ordered my box of Modern Masters 2017 for a steep discount…(information respectfully withheld.  Thanks!  You know who you are!)  Put it this way, I got a serious good deal.

Like the other “Masters” sets, this box only came with 24 packs.  But every pack contains a foil.  AND this time the set was loaded up with re-prints people have been asking for!

How did I fare?

This time I only have one picture, which will tell most of the story.

IMG_9853.jpg

I already put my rares away…sorry guys.  These are the commons and uncommons.  The story is “Return to Ravnica/Innistraad” srandard.  You could even draft deck archetypes with this set.

Maybe you can’t tell from the picture, but the stack of “gold” cards is about 1/3 taller than the traditional cards.  This is a set that wants you to build multi-color decks.

So what rares did I pull?

The notable ones were.

Marsh Flats

Gifts Ungiven

Linvala, Keeper of Silence

Griselbrand

Cavern of Souls

Goblin Guide

Abrupt Decay

Zur the Enchanter

Notably, I didn’t pull Snapcaster Mage, Liliana of the Veil, or Damnation.  I didn’t pull a Serum Visions or a Path to Exile either. But two awesome lands, Griselbrand, and the angel were all great pulls.

I decided to build a “cube commander” deck for Zur the Enchanter.  Basically a singleton deck with Esper colors.  I haven’t played it yet, but I know it will be janky when I do because there are only two valid enchantments!  (Seal of Doom and Gift of Orzova)

So did I draft?  Both me and the SpartanKid did so at the Tangled Web…$35 per entry fee…that’s steep!  But at $10 a pack, that’s why.

I think we both drafted traditional draft style decks.  Mine was based on “bloodrush”  Which was incredible Green Red strategy back in RtR block.  The SpartanKid drafted mono-white.  Probably not a great choice…but he crafted a successfully annoying Soul Sisters deck.  In fact, mine was annoying too if you were lucky!  Giantbaiting + Dragon Fodder+ Revive = YOU WIN.  But most of the time the opponent just had an early flier that I could only hold off for so long before I was ran over.

I did manage to draft Terminus, Obzedat, Goblin Guide, and Misty Rainforest.  But since I was in red green only the latter two made the cut…This set is so good that Misty Rainforest was actually passed to me!  I don’t know what they pulled….???

I wound up trading for a foil Damnation, and so I am all around happy with my investment.  If you read my blog, you know I have been burned a few times buying MTG boxes.  I felt confident that it would work out, and it did reasonably.

However, I did see “Rudy,” some You-Tube guy open a totally wack box, and follow that up with a box that contained all five fetch lands, Liliana, and Blood Moon.  So the potential for this to have gone either way in the other direction was there.

I was encouraged as one of my regular opponents sat beside me while I opened the packs from my box.  I was unaware of some of what I had.  I have a foil Grafdiggers Cage now.  Somehow that is a card that hasn’t been on my radar.  But I see incredible play value there now.  That guy also proclaimed jealousy when I opened Goblin Guide, and then drafted him as well!

I don’t know that I will get to draft this set anymore.  Opportunity dries up as the supply will.  If you read my previous post, you know I was looking forward to drafting Gifts Ungiven, or possibly pulling a foil Liliana of the Veil.  But I also realistically knew those were long shots.

I am going to refrain from rating this set based on my experience.  I have opened 27 packs and played with 24 of the cards, rather unsuccessfully.  I was fighting against myself as well, as I was really sick and started to get tired at around 10:00 PM.  I was making bonehead mistakes, like Traitorous Instinct on Ogre Jailbreaker, when I didn’t own a gate, for instance.  That really doesn’t say much for me and my skills on that day, and so I can’t rate it.  I do think the draft environment really wants you to aim for three colors.  At the Tangled Web, there are a few “fixer hogs.”  They take all of the fixers, and then they get to pick the best stuff on the last pack.  I can’t draft that way.  Maybe I should try it out.  But it seems I would rather know my strategy from the first twenty cards I draft.

SpartanNerd Thoughts…Modern Masters 2017

OK.  WOW!

What has me so enamored?

Liliana of the Veil

Snapcaster Mage

Damnation

Enemy Fetch Lands

Cavern of Souls

Gifts Ungiven (Can you imagine drafting this card?)

Double D (Desecration Demon…again, an amazing card to draft.)

Blood Moon

Tarmogoyf

Abrupt Decay

Domri Rade

Harmonize  (Green card draw…draft this!)

Path to exile

I mean…these are just some of the main cards everyone is talking about.  The reprinting of the top four…these have been called for by fans for a long time.  Liliana, Damnation, Snappy, and enemy fetches have all only ever been printed one time.  Their aftermarket values are super high.  Oh and Cavern of Souls too.

I think MTG has been in trouble.  At least Standard and Modern have been.  Standard, because “Stale Standard.”  Modern…It is so expensive to get the above staples, coupled with the Wizards stopped running Pro-Tour Modern events, and then the little fad called “Frontier.”  (Is is really just a fad?)  And MTG players love EDH…the top selling product for the Wizards is reportedly their yearly Commander release.

I look forward to drafting with these cards…that’s going to be great.  The cards scream ARCHETYPES!.  (Reanimator, Red-Green beatdown, Esper Blink, and so many more.)  And the box I pre-ordered…that is already an epic win.  If I don’t get Liliana or the D-word…I will pull something I want to trade for them.

I just keep going back to the card image gallery, and salivating.  Never have I been so pleased with a set.  I was psyched for Theros block releases.  But this goes beyond any hype…  Liliana and D….have been on the radar for a re-print.  The Wizards even said they considered her for M-15.  How that other card didn’t make it into “From the Vault: Annihilation,” I just don’t know.  We didn’t need another Wrath of God, especially with Heliod on it.

Back when they did the other two Modern Masters sets…people said, “Nah.  They won’t re-print Blood Moon or fetch lands.  That would be crazy.”  They have, people.  Draft and buy this thing.  And get back into Modern.  I’m getting bored!

(Technically, Tarmogoyf is the most valuable card up there in my list.  Not sure how…it has seen a few re-prints.  Yes.  Great card.  But in Modern, you pretty much need four copies of that $200 card in order to play the Zoo or Jund archetype decks.  Just saying!)

SpartanNerd…”Theros Block, I am going to miss you!”

Theros Block….I Am Going to Miss You
First of all, Theros Block is the first block that I am SUPER SAD to see rotate out of standard.  These are cards that I “just get.”  Everything from the Greek Fantasy flavor and motif, to the moody standard environment that the block created, both with Ravnica Block and Khans of Tarkir Block, as well as with the associated core sets M14, M15, AND Magic Origins.  Theros, Born of the Gods, and Journey Into Nyx have been terrific fun to play, study, and collect.  The set has taught me a lot about what kind of Magic player I am.  And it is the first set that I began to identify myself as a “serious player.”  The cards here are rotating out of Standard to make way for The Battle for Zendikar Block, but they will continue to reverberate through Modern, Legacy, and maybe even Vintage.  What cards will I miss?  Here are some of my thoughts about the cards.
Thoughtsieze.
IMG_7235

“Thought Sneeze” Why is he looking at his hands?

Wow.  The first card I ever paid big bucks for.  I opened two in booster packs, and paid $40 apiece for the other two.  Why was/is this card so expensive?  This card found its way into 90% of all of my standard decks over the past two years.  And it has been a staple in Modern.  Playable in a Rack deck, or Esper Control, Reanimator.  This card is one of the “nuts and bolts” of Magic the Gathering.  This card is similar to Snapcaster Mage….only “more available” currently.
I remember Thoughtsiezing out Stormbreath Dragons, Elspeth Sun’s Champion, all kinds of gods, other Thoughtsiezes, Pack Rats, Detention Spheres, and on and on the list goes.  This card became an essential part of Abzan decks as Khans of Tarkir block unfolded.  You could stop their Jeskai Ascendancy combo in its tracks, get rid of Ugin, get rid of Wingmate Roc, Siege Rhino, or Seeker of the Way.
In my circles, Modern tends to be a super fast format.  Thoughtsieze is a great sideboard card to slow down some of those opponents…taking out their Tarmogoyfs or Snapcaster Mages before they can do any good.  Someone offered me a trade for some of my Thoughtsiezes one day.  No way!  This card is currently “down in value,” which happens before rotation.  But this card could only go up in value again as it become rare again.
The other thing about the card is it lets you see the opponents hand.  I learned “write it down!”
Thoughtsieze, or as I have christened you, “Thought Sneeze, (even funnier because of the art), you will be missed in Standard.  Duress and Despise are only shadows of what you were!
Gray Merchant of Asphodel
IMG_7223
The card that got me my first ever TOP 8!.  I actually made it to the final round…facing an esper control player who favored Sphynx’s Revelation.  It was right after Born of the Gods came out…at the time, Ravnica Block also gave us Nightveil Spector, who was also an incredible card in the death machine that was Mono-Black Devotion.  You basically Pack Rat and Mutavault, eventually getting out Nightveil Spectors, excellent flying things that exiled away the opponents cards, acquired new resources for you, and provided three devotion to blue or black.  Then you dropped a Gray Merchant of Aspodel on the board, and GG.
When Ravnica Block rotated out, this strategy fought to remain in favor.  The Spectors really made it work.  Master of the Feast however usually proved unreliable because he would give them a card and they would either kill him, bounce him, tap him, or cancel your Gray Merchant.  Mono Black has been further undercut by Sphynx’s Tutelage, sadness for the SpartanNerd, (who really favors black.)
Gray Merchant, you will be remembered.  I don’t know that you will ever make waves again.  But you will be remembered.  I am storing away a playset in one binder slot for that off chance you actually do make a future splash!
Courser of Kruphix….
IMG_7231
A card I’m not going to miss.  And it’s not because I don’t own him.  Or even because I don’t like him.  (Either on my side of the field or theirs.)  The Courser of Kruphix reminds me of the time that I decided to stop playing Standard.  Why?  Because EVERYONE WAS PLAYING THE SAME DECK.  Abzan Aggro, Abzan Mid-Range, and Abzan Control all made use of the Courser.  Want to build a warrior deck?  Great.  But the courser will outlast you.  A burn deck (not the SpartanNerd.)  But the Courser’s ability to gain you life for playing lands takes away the point.  How about Jeskai decks with Prowess.  The Courser is a 2/4 big blocker.  In fact Some Jeskai players added green to their decks just because the Courser was so good.
I’ve said the downside of playing the Courser of Kruphix is that the opponent gets to see the top card of the library.  And it’s true, this WAS RELEVANT when the card first came out and people were still figuring him out.  But as Theros Block waxed long in the tooth, people figured out how to keep the revealed knowledge from being relevant.
The Courser of Kruphix was EVERYWHERE.  Both it and the Sylvan Caryatid seemed to always be in the same deck.
YAWN.
Speaking of the Sylvan Carytid
IMG_7226
This is the next card on my list!  I will not miss the Sylvan Carytid for the same reason I won’t be missing Thoughtsieze.  Now this card isn’t that expensive, and it has seen multiple printings also, getting honored in Event Decks, and also in the Clash Pack with alternate art.
The Sylvan Carytid isn’t quite Noble Hierarch.  But she approaches her.  This is a source of mana of any color, that is difficult to remove.  And it is also a big blocker on the ground for the early game.  Will this card fetch $30 – $60 someday?  I doubt it.  Like I said, not QUITE Noble Hierarch, (one of the greatest mana ramp cards ever.)
The Sylvan Carytid has helped me learn to build a four-color deck for the first time.  I decided to play in a PPTQ tournament at The Tangled Web Comic book store in Spartanburg SC, and I took my Esper “Gifts Ungiven” reanimator deck.  I remember one player telling me…”Wow.  This is a SLOW deck.”  I went home with big losses….(I won’t be playing in any more of those for a LONG time.)  But I decided to work on the problem.  Why was the deck so slow?  One of the reasons was the slow mana-base.  Sylvan Caryatid helped me fix this.  Not that it is a perfect deck yet…(I need at least two Snapcaster Mages and three Lilana, of the Veil.)  Still, my four-color deck featuring the Carytid and also Fleecemane Lion is far faster.  And the second claim I can make for it is that I have NEVER HAD MANA SCREW with the deck.
IMG_7224
Thank you, Sylvan Carytid.  Your teachings have been invaluable, and netted me two FNM tournament wins!
Bile Blight
IMG_7230 IMG_7227
Ahhh….the first ever box of Magic cards that I ever pre-ordered.  Born of the Gods.  (WAA…Waaa…waa)
Out of Thirty Six packs of cards, I was very interested in getting two cards.  Herald of Torment and Bile Blight.
I got NEITHER CARD.  OK, so the Herald was a rare.  I get that I wasn’t supposed to get him necessarily.  But BILE BLIGHT!  Uncommon.  i SHOULD have gotten at least one copy!
Nope.  I spent the whole weekend after I got my box going around Greenville, and even Hendersonville looking for copies of these cards.  I was able to come up with TWO copies.
Why was this uncommon gem so hard to find, with its price of less than a dollar?
The Born of the Gods EVENT DECK had TWO COPIES.  It is my theory, and just a theory, but probably a good one, that the Wizards held them back from he first wave of boxes, so that they could keep them uncommon and stuff them into the event decks.
Bile Blight is a super handy removal spell against token strategies.  Yes, it costs two blacks, demanding you to play Mono-Black devotion or similar.  And it was great in mirror matches.  When Mono-Black devotion died down, it was semi-OK against Elspeth.  The card is currently good against Hangarback Walker.  (It worked great against Pack Rat.)
I don’t think this card is going anywhere.  It is an efficient kill spell for one creature, or great at wiping out mana-elves, or hordes of tokens.  It works great against Fleecemane lion as well. Even if one of them is Monstrous, if you play the card right.  Have the Monstrous Fleecemane block some small critter and lose a little chunk, then hit a non-monstrous one on the battlefield with Bile Blight, and in perfect Magic World, you took care of a big problem.
For the rest of my story, I did eventually buy Herald of Torment…he never was expensive, and he really is just OK.  It was good to bestow him onto a Siege Rhino and fly in for the kill.  I eventually ordered the promo version of Bile Blight, which has creepier art with soldiers melting.  (No stores around here got copies of the promo.  I paid like $5 for it!  But it is a card I really like.)
IMG_7232
Bile Blight, I will keep you in my Modern toolbox.  As a player closely identified with black, I consider you as better than Doom Blade, Smother, or even Murderous Cut, or just Murder.  You can’t kill everything.  But you can -3/-3 things with indestructible.  And if played against the right deck, you can gain card advantage on the field.  Thank you for your service!
Scry Lands.
IMG_7234

I actually have about ten more of these in various decks.

I almost jumped for joy when the Wizards announced that Scry was going to become an evergreen ability.  YAY!
Scry Lands, you are slow.  Probably too slow for Modern, almost ever.  Definitely not shock lands or fetch lands.  Serum Visions kicks your butt.
But if you want fixing that you don’t miNd being a little slow with a small benefit attached, scry lands are better than say, “Refuges,” or “gain lands.”  And light years better than guildgates. (shudder.)
I will keep you around.  I expect you will be re-printed in the future, maybe with different art.  And then the Theros block Scry Lands will see value again.  We’ll see!
Erebos, God of the Dead
How could I create such a list and omit some Gods.  The God cards were the flagships of the Theros block.  There were five “major gods” and ten “minor gods.”
Here’s the list.
Heliod, God of the Sun
Thassa God of the Sea
Erebos, God of the Dead
Purphoros, God of the Forge
Nylea, God of the Hunt
Atheros, God of Passage
Ephara, God of the Polis
Iroas, God of Victory
Karametra, God of Harvests
Keranos, God of Storms
Kruphix, God of Horizons
Mogis, God of Slaughter
Pharika, God of Affliction
Phenax, God of Deception
Xenagos, God of Revels
IMG_7229

All of the Gods I have left. I have owned each one, but traded them.

There are only two truly significant cards on this list, Erebos and Thassa.  Basically the others were played around with, but might have made a mark for about a week and then disappeared.
Each of the major gods, (the first five listed,) had a weapon, and the weapons saw more play than the gods themselves.
But Erebos really stands a head taller than all of the others.  Mostly because of the Mono-Black Devotion deck.  In such a deck, Erebos is an unstoppable death machine.  If you can get him “turned on” by having five swamp symbols on the battlefield under your control, Erebos is incredible.  And his card draw ability is also really good if you only wish to view him as an enchantment.
IMG_7228
While Thassa and Nylea both THREATENED to create mono-colored devotion strategies, Erebos actually made it happen.  (i’m not being fair entirely.  Xenagos also sees a little bit of play.)
It seems like the Gods will be back whenever the Wizards bring Theros back in ten years or so.  They might just shift the whole thing to reflect Rome instead of Greece.  I wonder how they will change the gods?
The Whip of Erebos will also be missed.  That card really could wreak havoc if you were able to whip a Siege Rhino, or even better a Gray Merchant out of your graveyard, letting you drain your opponent with evil black devotion.  And the whip seems so innoccuous sometimes.  And then BAM.  Big problems.
IMG_7225
Erebos, I will miss you and your whip.  I don’t know if a mono-black strategy will ever resurge in Modern.  It seems viable.  There are plenty of cards that provide the devotion you need.  Phylactery Lich, Geralf’s Messenger, and on and on I could name.  The whip will find its way into reanimator decks I’m sure.
Elspeth, Sun’s Champion  (Not pictured)
Ah…Elspeth.  The control card of choice for such a long time.  You were expensive, then they re-printed you in the duel deck, Elspeth vs. Kiora.  (The art in that deck is even prettier than the original.)
Elspeth was mainly used to create white-weenie chumps as a finishing move for a control deck.  Occasionally, people would destroy a large creature with her roll-down ability.  But usually, she would get nine chumps on the field, and then an emblem, and they would all hammer you hard.
Bile Blight was good against the chumps.  But if you are in Bile Blight mode at that point in the game, it was usually over anyways.  (Remember, you are playing a control player.)
It got to where Hero’s Downfall was needed…
Hero’s Downfall…  (not pictured)
Similar to an earlier Rakdos card from Ravnica Block.  (Dreadbore).  This card was an instant kill for a creature or planeswalker.  I think this card will become a staple against planeswalkers if people aren’t playing red for that other card…
Stormbreath Dragon  (I don’t own a copy!)
I don’t own one of these.  Never have. Never will I don’t think.  (Not a red player.)
I won’t miss this guy beating my tail.  Enough said!
I loved Despising him out of my opponents hand.  This means I traded my 25-cent card for their $25 card.  But only if I was lucky.
Now for a few other cards rotating out…
Liliana Vess
IMG_7236

If the SpartanNerd was a magic card….

I literally SHOUTED when I saw they were re-printing Lilliana Vess for M15.  And I opened her at the pre-release, and used her to bring home a win.  (We actually split the box four ways…it was at a store at the beach that no longer has Magic tournaments, sadly.)  Lilliana.  I have this joke with my boys.  “I AM Lilliana.”  Which always gets a reaction from my youngest.
Few things are more satisfying in the game of Magic than re-animating every creature from every graveyard.  Lilliana can do this with her ultimate ability.  She is also a great card for tutoring up what you need.
I believe this to be her final re-print, unless they put her in some special set, reprint her for Commander, or similar.  This was her fifth printing, more than almost any other Planeswalker card.  (Lorwyn, M12, M13, Duel Decks Garruk vs. Lilliana, and M15.  There are actually six re-prints if you count the Duel Deck Anthology version.)
If Magic the Gathering has a villain, it is likely Nicol Bolas.  Lilliana is second place.  (Maybe Ob-Nixilis.)  (If not the Eldrazi)
I wish the Wizards had printed Lilliana of the Veil.  And according to their Making Magic articles, they almost did.  She would have been great!
I will set Lilliana back in her place of honor at the beginning of my Modern binder beside my other favorite cards, Grave Titan, and Elbrus, the Binding Blade.
and last but not least
Waste Not
IMG_7237
Waste Not represents a card that can be a “sleeper.”  One thing that I have learned from the Theros Block is about the “meta-game.”  What cards do people play?  What is popular?  What is popular at the Tangled Web as opposed to other places?  This is the meta-game.  And I have only met one other player brave enough/ stupid enough to try and rip a hole in the meta-game by playing a Waste Not deck.
Waste Not isn’t a valuable card.  I generally runs less than $5.  It has the distinction of being designed by the Magic Community.
I played a Waste Not deck in response to the flood of Abzan Decks with some success.  But I got tired of it.  People started expecting me to play it.  And then it was rendered pretty much useless by Sphynx’s Tutelage.
The point of the deck was load up stuff that forced the opponent to discard.  Thoughtsieze of course, Despise, and Durress.  There is an insane combo card for this in Dark Deal.  When the opponent discarded cards, good things would happen for you if Waste Not was on the field, and even more good things if multiple copies were on the field.  You would be generating Mana, drawing cards, or getting zombie tokens.
But zombie tokens don’t fly.  You can’t force the opponent to ditch lands apart from Black Cat or Dark Deal.  Too many discard spells become useless…if your opponent doesn’t have any cards in hand, then you have dead cards.  If the opponent gets a choice to discard a card, then they usually ditch a land.  (Kolaghan’s Command forces them to discard a card at instant speed, usually a land which generates mana that you usually can’t use.)
Waste Not was a fun card for me for awhile.  But I was never able to top-8 with a Waste Not deck.
I belive Waste Not to still be useful in an 8rack deck…I am building one.  But it just isn’t as fun as reanimator for me right now, so….
Hub City Geeks, what cards will you miss from the Theros Block (and M15.)  Let me know in the comments!